Is the Passion Over Net Neutrality Misguided? A New Paper Offers a Fresh Technical Approach

CircleID CircleID: "Net neutrality" is implicitly framed as a debate over how to deliver an equitable ration of quality to each broadband user and application. This is the wrong debate to have, since it is both technically impossible and economically unfair. We should instead be discussing how to create a transparent market for quality that is both achievable and fair. In this paper I propose an alternative approach that (potentially) meets the needs of both consumer advocates and free market proponents.

* * *

Broadband service quality: Rationing or markets? [Download PDF]Broadband is increasingly vital to everyday life, as well as to commerce and enterprise. Its importance merits asking the question: what is the appropriate role of government in managing the market for broadband services? For historical reasons, the primary agency tasked with answering that question in the US is the FCC.

The FCC has a long history of policing traditional telecom networks, and constraining the actions of players engaged in unfair practices. Over many decades, the FCC has found occasions where dominant carriers to have leveraged their market power to favor or disfavor other players. Whilst this inflates carrier profits, it demonstrably harms consumers.

The subject of "net neutrality" (called "Open Internet" in FCC rulemaking) is about the potential for ISPs to become "king makers" for online services. Its proponents position it as being about the potential for harmful "discrimination" by powerful ISPs. The topic generates diverse viewpoints that are promoted with intense feeling. This paper proposes that such passion is mostly misguided, as the current policy debate is misframed.

Consumer advocates have taken a language of fairness for living people, and then misapplied it to packets, whose ethereal nature barely qualifies as inanimate. As a consequence, they have inappropriately focused their "discrimination" concerns on the internal traffic management choices of packet networks. The resulting regulatory rules unwittingly enforce a grossly unfair rationing of service quality.

We can successfully reframe the policy problem to achieve a far fairer social and economic outcome. To do so, we must strip purely technical concerns of unwise and irrelevant emotive language. Terms like "discriminate", "throttle" and "violate" are used to fan public outrage, but come overladen with unhelpful semantic baggage. We need a new policy lexicon, one that clearly separates mechanistic network processes from orthogonal economic and legal issues.

Richer language and rational inquiry are our newfound friends; they help us to think with crisp precision about fairness concerns in the unfamiliar technology domain of distributed computing. Issues of equitable resource allocation need to be addressed at the human level, where they always belong.

The treatment of packets should only be relevant to the extent that a harm to people exists. Our goal then is to appropriately relate fairness to people to that of packet delivery. This can be achieved by focusing only on the external end-to-end service quality.

This paper proposed an alternative approach that (potentially) meets the needs of both consumer advocates and free market proponents. It constrains unfair ISP power, whilst also replacing rationing with a fairer market for quality. For this to come to pass, Congress has to express its will that it prefers fair markets over unfair rationing of broadband quality.
Written by Martin Geddes, Founder, Martin Geddes Consulting LtdFollow CircleID on TwitterMore under: Access Providers, Broadband, Net Neutrality, Networks, Policy & Regulation, Telecom

The post Is the Passion Over Net Neutrality Misguided? A New Paper Offers a Fresh Technical Approach appeared first on iGoldRush Domain News and Resources.

Continue reading

Pharma bro: The most hated domainer in America?

Martin Shkreli, also known as “pharma bro,” is on trial for securities fraud charges; the controversial 34-year-old faces up to 20 years behind bars if convicted. Shkreli gained notoriety after raising the price of an HIV drug by 5,000% during his tenure at Turing Pharmaceuticals. For this activity, Martin Shkreli has been referred to by […]

Copyright DomainGang

Continue reading

Petya Ransomware Spreading Rapidly Worldwide, Effecting Banks, Telecom, Businesses, Power Companies

CircleID CircleID: Supermarket 'Rost' in Kharkiv, East Ukraine – all the payment terminals appear to have been hit by the Petya ransomeware. (Photo posted on Twitter this morning by Mikhail Golub / @golub)

A large scale ransomware attack today is spreading rapid...

The post Petya Ransomware Spreading Rapidly Worldwide, Effecting Banks, Telecom, Businesses, Power Companies appeared first on iGoldRush Domain News and Resources.

Continue reading

Sedo weekly sales led by YMB.com

TheDomains TheDomains: Sedo released their weekly sales and YMB.com led the way at $35,000. okChina.com was number two at $32,500. Casino.co.jp sold for $20,000. I did contact Sedo and told them they put this in the wrong category. .Co.JP is the country code for Japan. I liked Shoppo.com for $10,000. There were a lot of names I […]
The post Sedo weekly sales led by YMB.com appeared first on TheDomains.com.

The post Sedo weekly sales led by YMB.com appeared first on iGoldRush Domain News and Resources.

Continue reading

Facebook crossed the 2 billion user mark

Facebook became the largest social media company in the known cosmos today, crossing 2 billion unique user accounts. The amazing feat was shared on Facebook by founder and CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, who stated: As of this morning, the Facebook community is now officially 2 billion people! We’re making progress connecting the world, and now let’s […]

Copyright DomainGang

Continue reading

How to create great content for your website

Whats Your Name Whats Your Name: Your website may have intuitive design, a flawless user experience, and compelling imagery—but at the end of the day, none of that matters if you’re lacking one very important thing: great content. Name.com’s Content Manager Ethan Conley and I recently sat down to talk about what it takes to create an incredible content strategy for […]
The post How to create great content for your website appeared first on Name.com Blog.

The post How to create great content for your website appeared first on iGoldRush Domain News and Resources.

Continue reading